Latest Blog: Fireside Reading - 03/01/2024
-
-
CIO INSIGHTS
-
CIO INSIGHTS
- BACK TO CIO INSIGHTS BACK TO ARTICLES & INSIGHTS HOME
-
-
-
Investment Insights are written by Angeles' CIO Michael Rosen
Michael has more than 30 years experience as an institutional portfolio manager, investment strategist, trader and academic.
WILD, WILD EAST
Published: 07-13-2015The central planners in Beijing have gotten so much right for the past three decades, that they might be forgiven for believing in their own infallibility. But it’s one thing to shuffle resources around an economy—a road here, an airport there—and quite another thing to dictate supply and demand in a large market. John Major learned the folly of fighting markets in 1992, and there have countless similar experiences both before and since.
Apparently confusing a healthy stock market with a healthy economy, the political powers in China decreed that stock prices should rise, directing banks and other lenders to lend freely to speculators. Margin loans on the “A” share market rose to $371 billion by mid-June, about 10% of the free-float market capitalization. By contrast, margin loans at the NYSE are around $500 billion, or 3% of the NYSE market capitalization. And that’s a record high in New York.
So the astute planners in Beijing decreed that margin lending had gotten ahead of itself, and shut off the spigot. As of last week, margin loans had fallen nearly 40%, to $238 billion, still about 8% of the capitalization of the A-shares market. The market itself fell more than 30%, and on Thursday of last week, the bureaucrats stepped in again to say that was enough, the market should stop falling. The chart below illustrates the extraordinary effect these decrees had on a daily basis. On Tuesday and Wednesday last week, most stocks were either limit-down or simply suspended from trading (91% on Tuesday, 80% on Wednesday), but then on Thursday 51% of stocks traded limit-up.
This is a crazy way to run a market (the oxymoron is not lost: market prices are not “run,” they reflect supply and demand forces). Still, I have some empathy for the bureaucrats. Setting reasonable rules and regulations and then stepping aside must be really hard to do. But they are learning that the alternative—decreeing the daily direction of markets—is even harder.
PRINT THIS ARTICLERELATED ARTICLES
-
Inside the Triangle 05-23-2016
Complexity makes investing so challenging. Unlike the pure sciences, there are no hard truths in investing, no ...
READ BLOG POST -
"Everything Human is Pathetic" 11-18-2022
This is what comes to my mind as I watch the debacle that is FTX imploding.Most legal documents and court filings are ...
READ BLOG POST -
Rick 12-16-2021
To fail or to suffice? It doesn't quite have the cadence of Shakespeare, admittedly. It is not the existential ...
READ BLOG POST
-
We strive build portfolios of best-in-class investment managers across all asset classes. If you would like to be considered for our portfolios, please contact us using our manager inquiries form.
- MANAGER INQUIRIES
-
SUBSCRIBE TO ANGELES' INSIGHTS
Get the latest investment information and stay on top of market trends.
SUBSCRIBE -
CONTACT US
SANTA MONICA
429 SANTA MONICA BLVD,
SUITE 650
SANTA MONICA, CA 90401
310.393.6300
GET DIRECTIONS -
NEW YORK
375 PARK AVENUE,
SUITE 2209
NEW YORK, NY 10152
212.451.9240
GET DIRECTIONS -
HOUSTON
5151 SAN FELIPE ST,
SUITE 1480
HOUSTON, TX 77056
713.832.3670
GET DIRECTIONS