Valuation

Most observers would agree that equities are rich (expensive, overpriced, etc.). Corporate profits are at record highs, and the forward price-to-(optimistic) earnings multiple on the S&P 500, at 17x, is the highest since 2004.

A favorite counterargument is a relative one: stocks may be expensive, but bonds are way more overvalued. With a 2% yield, the 10-year Treasury has a P/E multiple of 50x (taking the inverse of its yield). Of course, German bunds have an infinite P/E (with its negative yield). So stocks are the cheapest house in an expensive neighborhood.

That may be true, but this counterargument isn’t really a “counter,” i.e., stocks could still be expensive on their own even if other asset classes are more expensive.

The chart below (courtesy Barclays) shows the number of monthly observations of the S&P 500 at various forward P/E multiples (left y-axis). The subsequent average 12-month return is depicted by the black line (scaled to the right y-axis). And the range of subsequent 12-month returns at each P/E multiple is shown by the colors of each bar.

I like charts that convey a lot of information simultaneously (as this does), and this one leads me to three observations. The first two are pretty obvious/intuitive, the third, a bit more interesting:

• average future returns are higher when multiples are cheap than when multiples are expensive;
• negative forward returns can occur from both cheap and expensive multiples, although are more common when starting from an expensive base;
• forward returns have always been positive when multiples are in the middle range of valuation (as we are now).

I have not seen a rigorous study to explain this third point, but I’d speculate that the middle ground of valuation reflects an equilibrium environment that balances the macroeconomic risks of growth and inflation.

Of course, no law governs this observation, and the future path of equity prices is unknown. But in weighing the evidence, I see no compelling reason to deviate from our long-term strategy.

• 3 Jan, 2018

  Updating the Triangle

  Last year, I introduced my big picture framework of assessing the relative attractiveness of markets Inside the Triangle ...

• 11 Nov, 2014

  Logistics

  Not enough attention is being paid to the work slowdown/stoppage going on at West Coast ports.The last time there was a ...

• 22 Dec, 2014

  Too Many Words

  Among monetary economists, there is a raging debate over the merits of the Fed's burgeoning balance sheet. Back in ...