Puerto Pobre

An honest politician may be oxymoronic (or is just moronic?), or maybe it’s the black swan that surprises us when seen. Either way, Alejandro Garcia Padilla, governor of the US Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, stated in clear terms a 5-year old could understand (which thus qualifies it as a black swan of political clarity) that Puerto Rico cannot pay its debts; period.

This island of 3.5 million very nice people, with a GDP less than Sacramento, has amassed debts of $72 billion. As is so often (always?) the case, excessive debt is not the disease, it is a symptom of the disease. In Puerto Rico’s case, its GDP has been falling for a decade, only 40% of the working-age population works, and people are fleeing the island for the US mainland. Obviously, these three developments are all linked (see Graph below).

A decade ago (2002), Congress removed the generous tax breaks for companies doing business in Puerto Rico, and businesses pulled out, proving that there was no reason to be in Puerto Rico (cheap labor, productive workers, low taxes and regulations) but for the US federal tax exemption. Forced to compete, Puerto Rico couldn’t, or rather, didn’t. Instead, successive governors continued to grow the size of government. The most recent smart idea from Mr. Garcia Padilla is to raise the sales tax from 7% to 11.5%.

I don’t know why I am continually astonished with the absence of economic sense among politicians and pundits. I’m just politically naive, I suppose. Pro-market reforms—limited taxes and regulations, labor flexibility, etc.—lead to economic growth and prosperity wherever they have been adopted (much of Asia as exemplar primus). The opposite policies lead to stagnation and poverty. This is not theory, just empirical fact.

A restructuring of Puerto Rico’s debt is inevitable, as it is with Greece and others (Venezuela comes to mind). But absent pro-market reforms, no amount of debt restructuring (default/forgiveness/reduction) will avoid a repeat of this cycle. Delay, yes; avoid, no.

• 10 Sep, 2020

  Still Beach Reading

  It's still beach weather here in Southern California, so I have a few more suggestions for beach reading.Begin Again by ...

• 8 May, 2024

  Beach Reading

  I'm happy to go to the beach year-round, but it's now really becoming beach weather, so I have five new book suggestions ...

• 1 Apr, 2015

  New Owners

  A few years, I was at a conference, standing in a buffet line. I must have become fixated on extracting the blueberries ...